Deciding what is essential is only half the job. Once a government knows what it must keep, Amendment 3 still leaves less money to pay for it. Statewide, counties and cities lose about a seventh of their property-tax revenue in the first year, and about a third once the cut is fully phased in.
The usual answer is a percentage cut to every department. It feels fair. It also guarantees worse service, because it changes the number of people doing the work without changing the work. The same steps, the same handoffs and the same approvals stay in place, now with fewer hands. The queue gets longer, and residents notice.
There’s a better question to ask: what does it actually take to deliver each essential service, and how much of that effort does the resident never see or value?
Every service is a process
Residents experience the result: a permit issued, a pothole filled, a 911 call answered. The cost sits in the steps behind it.
Picture a pothole report. A resident calls or uses an app. Someone logs it. Someone else reviews it. A supervisor assigns it. A crew is scheduled, travels, repairs it, and reports back. Someone closes the ticket. Each step takes time and money. Some steps exist because a problem happened once, years ago, and nobody removed the fix when the problem went away.
You can’t see that from a budget line. You can see it by walking the process with the people who do the work, from request to done, and measuring four things:
- Count: how many requests, permits or calls, and how many get done.
- Time: how long from request to completion, and how much of that is waiting.
- Money: what each one costs to deliver.
- Quality: how often it’s done right the first time, and how often it comes back.
The ratios tell the story: cost per permit, days per repair, percent reworked. Most governments track the count. Far fewer track the other three for the same service.
What Baldrige asks
The Baldrige Excellence Framework puts the question plainly in its Operations category:
“How do you manage the cost, efficiency, and effectiveness of your operations? How do you
- incorporate cycle time, productivity, and other efficiency and effectiveness factors into your work processes;
- reduce variability and prevent defects, service errors, and rework;
- reduce waste associated with your products and/or services and their production;
- minimize warranty costs or customers’ productivity losses, as appropriate;
- minimize the costs of inspections, tests, and process or performance audits, as appropriate; and
- balance the need for cost control and efficiency with the requirements and expectations of your customers and other stakeholders?”
The last bullet matters most this year. Efficiency without customer requirements just means cutting faster. That’s why this article comes after Start With Who You Serve. You need to know what residents require from a service before you can tell which steps add value and which only add cost.
Lean and Six Sigma, plainly
Two well-tested methods do most of the work here.
Lean looks for steps that add nothing the customer values: waiting, handoffs, re-entering the same information, approvals nobody reads, trips back for a missing form. Remove those, and the service gets faster and cheaper at the same time.
Six Sigma looks for why a process produces errors and rework, and reduces the variation that causes them. A permit application that gets sent back twice is handled three times, and frustrates the applicant every time.
Neither method requires a large consulting contract. Both require staff time, a few trained people to lead the work, and leaders willing to act on what they find.
Where to look first
Start with high-volume, repeatable work, where a small saving per transaction adds up: permits and inspections, utility billing, code complaints, records requests, purchasing, hiring.
Don’t skip the support processes. Baldrige lists accounting, purchasing, human resource management and regulatory compliance among them. They rarely appear on a resident’s list of essential services, but every department waits on them. A purchasing process that takes six weeks slows every service that depends on it.
Start this month
- Pick three high-volume processes that support essential services.
- Walk each one, request to done, with the people who do the work. Write down every step.
- Measure count, time, money and quality, and set a target for each.
- Decide before you start what happens to the time you free up. If staff believe improvement leads to layoffs, they will stop telling you where the waste is. Most governments can capture savings through attrition and redeploy people to the services residents ranked highest.
Florida’s Sterling Council assesses organizations against the full framework, including Operations. Its examiners return a written view of where a government’s processes are strong and where they leak time and money.
Disclosure: I serve on the Sterling Council’s board of directors.
Every government will spend less next year. The ones that study their own work first will lose less service for each dollar they cut.
Which process in your government would you walk first?
